Mystery Box Sale

Once a year I open up my personal inventory and turn it into mystery boxes. Brand new pieces, factory-refurbished classics, and vintage Cutco that came back to me over 22 years of doing this.

Every box is packed by hand, every piece is covered by Cutco's Forever Guarantee, and every box is worth almost double what you pay. 37 boxes. When the counter says sold out, that's the whole sale.

Pick Your Box

Core Mystery Box
$250.00

$250 in, $450+ out, guaranteed. Big enough to set someone up, small enough to be an easy yes. No brainer in my opinion.

  • Guaranteed $450+ retail value

  • At least 4 pieces

  • At least 2 brand new pieces

  • Every piece covered by the Forever Guarantee

  • 10 available

Only 7 available
Small Mystery Box
$150.00

Grab one for yourself, grab one as a birthday gift you don't have to think about. Either way it opens like a present.

  • Guaranteed $250+ retail value

  • 2-3 pieces in every box

  • At least 1 brand new piece

  • Every piece covered by the Forever Guarantee

  • 22 available

Elite Mystery Box
$500.00

For the Cutco lover and the deal lover. $500 in, $1,000+ out, eight pieces minimum. The most interesting box on the page.

  • Guaranteed $1,000+ retail value

  • 8 pieces minimum

  • At least 3 brand new pieces

  • Every piece covered by the Forever Guarantee

  • 5 available

Only 3 available